07-Nov-2009 20:48pm
 
RealTime Fantasy Sports
GOLDBERG ON FOOTBALL: Injuries kill everyone but the Patriots

By DAVE GOLDBERG - AP Football Writer
    2007-11-21 17:41

In the opening week of the season, the St. Louis Rams lost Orlando Pace, one of the NFL's best offensive linemen.

In the next few weeks, most of the remaining offensive linemen went down, along with backups and backups to backups. Quarterback Marc Bulger and running back Steven Jackson also went out, and the Rams started 0-8.

So it was no surprise that after they won their first game two weeks ago with three offensive linemen who had been picked up off the street, coach Scott Linehan quipped: ``We didn't have an O-lineman scheduled for surgery. That's an improvement.''

The Rams are the classic example of how injuries kill in the modern NFL, where lack of depth is legislated - the salary cap doesn't allow teams to stockpile first-class reserves behind starters.

It wasn't that way before the advent of free agency and the salary cap in 1993, when teams that scouted and drafted well often had backups who could start elsewhere and could be plugged in if a starter went down.

Look at the 49ers, who from 1987-90 had Steve Young as a backup to Joe Montana, one future Hall of Famer caddying for another.

In 1990, the New York Giants lost quarterback Phil Simms and replaced him with Jeff Hostetler, who was in his sixth season with the team. In his early years, he was so starved for action he convinced Bill Parcells to play him on special teams and as a spare wide receiver. But he was a good enough QB to step in for Simms, lead the team to the Super Bowl and then win it.

Hostetler went to the Raiders as a free agent in 1993, something he might have done earlier but couldn't under the rules at the time. The same process worked for a lot of teams in the pre-free-agency era; the Redskins used to stockpile players on ``injured reserve,'' winning Super Bowls after the 1983, 1987 and 1991 seasons with three different QBs, the last with Mark Rypien, one of those held in reserve until needed.

No one can do that these days.

When Jacksonville lost David Garrard for three games, it had to go with Quinn Gray, a third-string quarterback in his first two seasons. Gray started three games and won two, but Garrard's return last week was clearly a needed lift for the Jaguars' offense.

Houston started 2-0, then lost wide receiver Andre Johnson with a knee injury. The Texans were 2-5 during his absence, then beat New Orleans last week as he returned with six catches for 120 yards, including a 73-yard TD.

Even a team as good as Indianapolis can't afford to lose stars.

With Marvin Harrison playing the first six games, Peyton Manning had 11 TD passes and three interceptions and the Colts were unbeaten. Harrison has missed the last four, the Colts are 2-2 and Manning has thrown for five touchdowns with eight interceptions.

Let's go the eternal grump, coach Tom Coughlin of the Giants.

Even with his team 6-2, the hypercritical New York media and the ESPN yappers kept pointing out the Giants started that way last season, then ``collapsed'' to lose six of eight. Trying to stick to his new ``nice Tom'' persona, Coughlin pointed out that the collapse came largely because Michael Strahan, Amani Toomer, Luke Petitgout and Osi Umenyiora were hurt. As were others.

``Injuries, injuries,'' he kept saying. ``That's what happened to us. There was no choke. It was just a lot of people getting hurt.''

Coughlin's team was relatively injury free this season until last week, when it beat Detroit but lost linebacker Matthias Kiwanuka for the season with a broken leg. Running back Brandon Jacobs hurt his hamstring. The good news: RB might be New York's deepest position.

That's often a deciding factor - a team that's lucky has injuries at positions where the backups are capable.

But sometimes even that doesn't work.

Kansas City, for example, thought it was well-protected at running back behind Larry Johnson with Priest Holmes. So it traded Michael Bennett to Tampa Bay after the Bucs lost Carnell ``Cadillac'' Williams.

Then Johnson hurt his foot and the 34-year-old Holmes decided to retire. Now all the Chiefs have left is Kolby Smith, who wasn't even a regular in college.

The Colts are an example of a team with the worst kind of injury luck, having a bunch of players out at the same position, in this case at receiver.

Not only has Harrison been hurt, but so has rookie Anthony Gonzalez, the No. 3 wideout. Tight end Dallas Clark missed a loss in San Diego when Manning threw six interceptions, and last week Aaron Moorehead, the No. 4, went down with a back injury. So one of Peyton's primary targets is Craphonso Thorpe, who was on and off the practice squad for two seasons.

Injuries are a major factor in the downfall of last season's other Super Bowl team, Chicago.

Yes, inconsistency at quarterback and the failure of running back Cedric Benson have contributed. But so did the decimation of the secondary, led by what seems like the annual season-ending injury to safety Mike Brown, who might be - next to Brian Urlacher - the second-most important player on the defense. With cornerback Nathan Vasher missing seven games with a groin injury, the entire secondary had to be reshuffled. So a team that went 13-3 and allowed 255 points in 16 games last season is 4-6 and has allowed 217 points in 10.

There is, of course, an exception: New England, of course.

The Patriots are an exception to everything these days, including the rule that every team is supposed to be close to .500. And even when they have had injuries, they've survived. Hey, they won a Super Bowl with Troy Brown, a wide receiver, as the nickel back in a secondary that had lost several real DBs with injuries.

Even through this unbeaten season, when they've been winning games by an average of 41-16, the Patriots haven't been injury free.

Richard Seymour, one of the NFL's best defensive linemen, was on the physically unable to perform list to start the season and has seen spot duty in the last three games. They've been without their top two running backs, Laurence Maroney and Sammy Morris, for much of the season, and Morris is gone for the year.

But the Patriots were able to fill in with the versatile Kevin Faulk and Heath Evans, nominally a fullback. They filled the hole created by Seymour with the more-than-capable Jarvis Green, who they've managed to keep for six years as a pass-rush specialist, presumably enticing him to stay with the promise of Super Bowl rings. As a starter, he's been solid against the run and is second on the team with four sacks.

The way this season is going for New England, it could probably afford to lose any player but Tom Brady and still cruise to the title.

Don't bet on Brady going down. Even though Bill Belichick has been listing him on the injury list every week for years with a ``shoulder,'' Brady will make his 105th straight start Sunday.

---

DIRTY DOZEN: The top six and bottom six teams in the NFL based on current level of play.

1. New England (10-0). Can the Patriots be promoted to a higher league?

---

2. *Green Bay (9-1). Mike McCarthy is coach of the year.

3. *Dallas (9-1). Jason Campbell exposed the secondary last week.

4. *Indianapolis (8-2). Get 10 days after Thanksgiving to get healthy.

5. Jacksonville (7-3). Injury factor makes Jags a threat to the Colts.

6. New York Giants (7-3) Defense rebounded from Dallas loss with solid game in Detroit.

27. Cincinnati (3-7). Playing like the old Bungles, pre-Marvin Lewis.

28. *New York Jets (2-8). Two straight OT games, one a win. Sign of life?

29. *Atlanta (3-7). Why did Bobby Petrino bench Harrington?

30. Oakland (2-8). Will Al Davis give Lane Kiffin the freedom to build?

31. San Francisco (2-8). Hired a new offensive ``consultant,'' Ted Tollner. That's desperation.

32. Miami (0-10). Still might be a win on a schedule that includes the Jets, Bengals and Ravens.

---

*-Not counting Thursday games.


Recommend this story: Email to a friend Submit to Digg.com Submit to Del.icio.us Save to Technorati.com

Fantasy Football Player Notes RSS FeedPLAYER NOTES

Ryan McBeanNov 7 05:33p

Denver Broncos DE Ryan McBean (knee) did not participate in practice Saturday, Nov. 7. He has been ruled out for Week 9.

Ryan HarrisNov 7 05:33p

Denver Broncos OT Ryan Harris (toe) did not participate in practice Saturday, Nov. 7. He has been ruled out for Week 9.

Alvin PearmanNov 7 05:03p

Jim Wyatt, of The Tennessean, reports Tennessee Titans RB Alvin Pearman is expected to be the team's punt and kick returner in Week 9.

Muhsin MuhammadNov 7 04:43p

Panthers.com reports Carolina Panthers WR Muhsin Muhammad (knee) did not travel with the team for their Week 9 game.

Brad HooverNov 7 04:43p

Panthers.com reports Carolina Panthers FB Brad Hoover (ankle), FS Charles Godfrey (ankle) and TE Dante Rosario (knee) did not travel with the team for their Week 9 game.

Kendrick ClancyNov 7 04:33p

Adam Schefter, of ESPN.com, reports the New Orleans Saints have placed DT Kendrick Clancy (knee) on Injured Reserve, ending his 2009 season.

Travis KirschkeNov 7 04:23p

Mark Kaboly, of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, reports Pittsburgh Steelers DE Travis Kirschke (calf) and LB Lawrence Timmons (ankle) both said they will not be able to play in Week 9.

Jack WilliamsNov 7 12:03p

The Denver Broncos announced Saturday, Nov. 7, that they have waived CB Jack Williams.

Greg EllisNov 7 11:13a

Jerry McDonald, of ANG Newspapers, reports Oakland Raiders DL Greg Ellis (knee) underwent successful arthroscopic surgery on his arthritic knee. Head coach Tom Cable would not rule Ellis out [ More ]

Al HarrisNov 7 01:13a

The Associated Press reports Green Bay Packers DL B.J. Raji, DL Johnny Jolly and CB Al Harris have each been fined $5,000 by the NFL for their actions Week [ More ]

Jason FergusonNov 6 08:33p

Miami Dolphins DT Jason Ferguson (elbow) and LB Channing Crowder (shoulder) were limited in practice Friday, Nov. 6, but both are listed as doubtful for Week 9.

Devin HesterNov 6 08:33p

Brad Biggs, of the Chicago Sun-Times, reports Chicago Bears WR Devin Hester (ankle) was limited in practice Friday, Nov. 6. He is listed as questionable for Week 9, [ More ]

Jack WilliamsNov 6 07:03p

Denver Broncos CB Jack Williams (illness) and SS David Bruton (groin) fully participated in practice Friday, Nov. 6. They are expected to play in Week 9.

Calvin JohnsonNov 6 07:03p

Nicholas J. Cotsonika, of the Detroit Free Press, reports Detroit Lions WR Calvin Johnson (knee) practiced Friday, Nov. 6, and is expected to play in Week 9. He looked [ More ]

Scott StarksNov 6 07:03p

Jacksonville Jaguars CB Scott Starks (hamstring) did not participate in practice Friday, Nov. 6. He has been ruled out for Week 9.

Josh BarrettNov 6 06:53p

Denver Broncos FS Josh Barrett (undisclosed) was limited during practice Friday, Nov. 6. He will be a game-time decision for Week 9 but should play.

Kevin SmithNov 6 06:53p

Nicholas J. Cotsonika, of the Detroit Free Press, reports Detroit Lions RB Kevin Smith (shoulder) practiced Friday, Nov. 6, and is expected to play in Week 9.

Jeremiah RatliffNov 6 06:43p

Dallas Cowboys DT Jay Ratliff (knee) and SS Gerald Sensabaugh (thumb) participated in practice Friday, Nov. 6. They are listed as probable for Week 9 and will be able to play.

Demetric EvansNov 6 06:23p

Matt Maiocco, of The Santa Rosa Press Democrat, reports San Francisco 49ers DL Demetric Evans (shoulder) did not practice Friday, Nov. 6, and will not play in Week 9.

Takeo SpikesNov 6 06:23p

Matt Maiocco, of The Santa Rosa Press Democrat, reports San Francisco 49ers LB Takeo Spikes (shoulder) practiced in full Friday, Nov. 6, and is expected to play in Week 9.

Reggie SmithNov 6 06:23p

Matt Maiocco, of The Santa Rosa Press Democrat, reports San Francisco 49ers CB Reggie Smith (groin) practiced in full Friday, Nov. 6, and is probable for Week 9. He will be a game-time decision.

Kelvin HaydenNov 6 06:23p

Indianapolis Colts CB Kelvin Hayden (knee) did not participate in practice Friday, Nov. 6. He has been ruled out for Week 9.

Stephen SpachNov 6 06:03p

Darren Urban, of AZCardinals.com, reports Arizona Cardinals TE Stephen Spach (ankle) practiced in full Friday, Nov. 6, and is probable for Week 9. He will be available, but might [ More ]

David StewartNov 6 06:03p

Jim Wyatt, of The Tennessean, reports Tennessee Titans OT David Stewart (hamstring) did not participate in practice Friday, Nov. 26. He is listed as questionable for Week 9 and [ More ]

Nick FergusonNov 6 05:53p

Houston Texans DL Tim Bulman (ribs), LB Xavier Adibi (ankle), LB Kevin Bentley (shoulder) and SS Nick Ferguson (knee) are expected to play in the team's Week 9 game.

Benjamin WatsonNov 6 05:43p

New England Patriots TE Benjamin Watson (back) was limited during practice Friday, Nov. 6. He is listed as questionable for Week 9 and will be a game-time decision.

Matt LightNov 6 05:33p

New England Patriots WR Julian Edelman (forearm), RB Fred Taylor (ankle), RB Sammy Morris (knee), OT Matt Light (knee) and DL Jarvis Green (knee) did not participate in practice [ More ]

Donald BrownNov 6 05:13p

Indianapolis Colts RB Donald Brown (shoulder) did not practice Friday, Nov. 6, and is questionable for Week 9.

Pierre GarconNov 6 05:13p

Indianapolis Colts WR Pierre Garcon (ankle) did not practice Friday, Nov. 6, and is questionable for Week 9.

Sinorice MossNov 6 05:13p

Ralph Vacchiano, of the New York Daily News, reports New York Giants WR Sinorice Moss (foot) and WR Mario Manningham (shoulder) will be able to play in Week 9.

Chris CantyNov 6 05:13p

Ralph Vacchiano, of the New York Daily News, reports New York Giants DT Chris Canty (calf) and LB Michael Boley (knee) are expected to play in Week 9.

Dominique BarberNov 6 05:13p

Houston Texans SS Dominique Barber (ankle) did not practice Friday, Nov. 6, and will not play in Week 9.

RSS Feeds

NFL News:
 
Player Notes:
 
Forum Posts: