BCS officials risk overcomplicating a playoff system

Sat May 5, 2012 6:30am
By the National Football Post

Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany met with members of the media this past Wednesday in Chicago and discussed one possible way of determining a national champion in college football once a four-team playoff is implemented in 2014.

Delany said that a "conference champion only" model is being discussed that would include teams that won their leagues, but the squads would only qualify if they were ranked among the top six teams in the country.

For instance, if a team such as Alabama won the SEC and was among the top six teams in the rankings (perhaps a tweaked version of the current BCS standings), the Crimson Tide would automatically qualify for the playoff and be one of the top four ranked conference champs to qualify among the top six.

If there are less than four conference champs among the final top six, however, then the remaining spot or spots in the playoff would be filled by the highest ranked non-champ or, in the case of Notre Dame or BYU, an independent if that team is in the top six (So if Nos. 1, 2, and 6 are conference champs and Nos. 3, 4, and 5 are not, then Nos. 1, 2, 6 and 3 would qualify for a four-team playoff).

Of course, we already know that SEC commissioner Mike Slive wants the playoff participants to simply be the top four teams in the final rankings, the idea being those teams are the strongest no matter if it was a league champion.

Larry ScottPac-12 commissioner Larry Scott, like Big Ten boss Jim Delany, prefers the four-team playoff to include conference champs only.

Pac-12 commissioner Larry Scott, like Delany, prefers including conference champs only.

One of the bigger debates surrounding a future playoff system has been how to rank the teams and which squads would be eligible for a four-team model. I would prefer that the current BCS ranking system be tweaked to include other factors such as strength of schedule. Others, however, have suggested that using a selection committee would be the best option, and a committe is something that Delany said he prefers.

Revenue distribution among all of the conferences is also another issue, especially with the AQ and non-AQ statuses likely to be shed after 2013. At the meeting in Chicago, Delany wouldn't divulge any information when the revenue topic was broached. He did remain optimistic, however, that the new playoff model would be finalized in time to present it to the Presidential Oversight Committee for approval June 20 in Chicago.

If we take a look back and see how Delany's plan would have affected a few previous postseasons, 11-1 third-ranked Michigan would not have made a four-team playoff in 2006. That bid would have gone to Big East champion Louisville, which also was 11-1. Imagine the uproar in Ann Arbor if that had occured.

In 2008, No. 4 Alabama would not have advanced to a four-team playoff either because No. 2 Florida was the SEC champ, defeating the Crimson Tide in Atlanta. Nick Saban's squad would have been left out, along with No. 3 Texas, because No. 5 USC and No. 6 Utah were conference champs that year.

My fear is that the plan discussed by Delany is too complex for a sport that is already thriving. While I am not a proponent of anything more than a Plus-One, the fact is that a four-team playoff is on the horizon. Why toss around confusing proposals? Despite various factors to work through on our way to a playoff, why not try to make things as simple as possible by inviting the top four teams — conference champ or not — to the playoff? Doesn't a system lose some credibility if teams ranked Nos. 1-4 at the end of the year aren't the teams in a four-team playoff? Even if we have the two top-ranked conference champions and select two at-large teams, it still wouldn't top the alternative. Either way, we will still hear complaints about the teams occupying the No. 5 and No. 6 spots in a four-team playoff system. I would simply argue that the No. 3 and No. 4 teams have made stronger cases.

Whether or not the current BCS standings are tweaked or if a committee is put together to select the playoff teams, simplicity should be the general rule of thumb for these decision-makers. The current system is without a doubt a bit flawed. And change is coming. But if the BCS officials aren't careful, they can ruin what is already a pretty good thing — the best regular season in sports and a postseason that fuels unlimited discussion, for good or for bad.

Email dave.miller@nationalfootballpost.com or follow me on Twitter at Miller_Dave

Follow @footballpost on Twitter for the latest news

Fantasy Football Player Notes RSS FeedPLAYER NOTES

Lamar MillerMay 22 11:25a

Miami Dolphins RB Lamar Miller worked predominantly with the first-team offense, but RBs Daniel Thomas, Mike Gillislee and Marcus Thigpen also saw carries Tuesday, May 21, in organized team activities (OTAs).

Brian UrlacherMay 22 11:23a

Free-agent MLB Brian Urlacher (Bears) retired after 13 seasons.

DeMarco MurrayMay 22 11:12a

The Dallas Cowboys are taking a cautious approach with RB DeMarco Murray (hamstring) as he deals with a slight hamstring tweak, according to head coach Jason Garrett.

Manti Te'oMay 22 11:10a

San Diego Chargers LB Manti Te'o has been looking good during the team's organized team activities this week, but the team hasn't been in pads yet. Te'o displayed good [ More ]

Ryan TannehillMay 22 11:06a

Miami Dolphins QB Ryan Tannehill was sharp during organized team activities Tuesday, May 21. Tannehill had big passes to WRs Brian Hartline and Mike Wallace. TE Dustin Keller was [ More ]

Antonio JohnsonMay 22 10:53a

The Tennessee Titans signed DT Antonio Johnson to a one-year deal worth $850,000. He has an $800,000 base salary and a $50,000 roster bonus.

Wes WelkerMay 22 10:44a

Denver Broncos WR Wes Welker knows that with WRs Demaryius Thomas and Eric Decker in the picture on his new team, he won't be averaging 112 catches in 2013 [ More ]

Christine MichaelMay 22 10:44a

Seattle Seahawks RB Christine Michael (hamstring) and CB Tharold Simon (foot) were limited in organized team activities Monday, May 20. RB Robert Turbin had the chance to take first-team [ More ]

Fendi OnobunMay 22 09:43a

The Chicago Bears' depth chart at tight end after TE Martellus Bennett is wide open. TE Fendi Onobun could seize an opportunity for playing time.

T.J. YatesMay 22 08:43a

Houston Texans head coach Gary Kubiak said QB Case Keenum could unseat QB T.J. Yates for the backup quarterback spot.

Mario FanninMay 22 08:33a

The Denver Broncos waived RB Mario Fannin and placed S Blake Gideon on the reserve-retired list.

Darrelle RevisMay 21 11:53p

Tampa Bay Buccaneers CB Darrelle Revis (knee) has been cleared to cut and change directions. 'I feel very confident,' Revis said Tuesday, May 21.

Michael EgnewMay 21 11:53p

Miami Dolphins TE Michael Egnew began team drills in organized team activities (OTAs) Tuesday, May 21, ahead of TE Dustin Keller. Head coach Joe Philbin said Egnew earned the reps after a strong offseason.

Charles WoodsonMay 21 11:53p

The Oakland Raiders agreed to terms with free-agent CB Charles Woodson (Packers) on a one-year, $1.8 million contract Tuesday, May 21.

Nate GarnerMay 21 11:53p

Miami Dolphins OG Nate Garner rotated in at left guard and center during organized team activities (OTAs) Tuesday, May 21. He was the team's backup right tackle last season.

M. BernadeauMay 21 09:13p

Dallas Cowboys OG David Arkin and OL Ronald Leary split time at right guard during organized team activities (OTAs) Tuesday, May 21, with OG Mackenzy Bernadeau (shoulder) still recovering from offseason shoulder surgery.

Will AllenMay 21 09:13p

Dallas Cowboys SS Will Allen rotated with FS Matt Johnson Tuesday, May 21, during organized team activities (OTAs), working opposite SS Barry Church.

Aldon SmithMay 21 09:13p

San Francisco 49ers LB Aldon Smith (shoulder) is still recovering from labrum surgery during the offseason. He has been doing a 'little bit' of work at the start of organized team activities (OTAs).

Morris ClaiborneMay 21 09:13p

Dallas Cowboys CB Morris Claiborne has bulked up from 185 pounds to 193 pounds during the offseason. He said Tuesday, May 21, that he is getting used to the [ More ]

Jason GarrettMay 21 09:13p

Dallas Cowboys team owner and general manager said Tuesday, May 21, that head coach Jason Garrett is 'not coaching for his job this year.'

Doug FreeMay 21 09:13p

Dallas Cowboys OTs Doug Free and Jermey Parnell split time at right tackle during the first day of organized team activities (OTAs) Tuesday, May 21.

Anquan BoldinMay 21 09:13p

San Francisco 49ers QB Colin Kaepernick and WRs A.J. Jenkins and Ricardo Lockette lived together for two months in Atlanta during the offseason, working together at a nearby training [ More ]

DeMarcus WareMay 21 09:03p

Dallas Cowboys DT Jay Ratliff and DE DeMarcus Ware did not participate in team drills Tuesday, May 21, during the first day of organized team activities (OTAs).

Bruce AriansMay 21 08:03p

Arizona Cardinals head coach Bruce Arians was disappointed with his team during organized team activities Tuesday, May 21, and he singled out several players for making mental mistakes two [ More ]

Max StarksMay 21 06:33p

San Diego Chargers OT Max Starks, who was signed to an undisclosed one-year deal Tuesday, May 21, is likely to become the team's starting left guard this year. Starks [ More ]

Tony RomoMay 21 05:53p

Dallas Cowboys QB Tony Romo (back) said he didn't know about the cyst on his back when he signed a six-year, $108 million extension in March. Romo said he [ More ]

Max StarksMay 21 05:43p

The San Diego Chargers signed OT Max Starks (Steelers) Tuesday, May 21. Terms of the deal were not disclosed.

Dez BryantMay 21 05:03p

Dallas Cowboys WR Dez Bryant said he found himself, and that has led to a quiet offseason with no off-field issues. 'I found myself,' Bryant said Tuesday after the [ More ]

Jeff KingMay 21 04:43p

Arizona Cardinals TE Jeff King (knee) underwent knee surgery early in the offseason. The coaching staff hopes King can return to practice in early June.

Jordan CameronMay 21 04:13p

The Cleveland Browns really like TE Jordan Cameron as their starting tight end and have been targeting him a lot in organized team activities.

Jerel WorthyMay 21 03:53p

Green Bay Packers DT Jerel Worthy (knee) said he is going to play again at some point in 2013 after tearing his anterior cruciate ligament in Week 17.

Mike GoodsonMay 21 03:13p

New York Jets RB Mike Goodson will plead not guilty to all charges, with the most serious being a second-degree unlawful possession of a firearm. If convicted, Goodson would [ More ]

RSS Feeds

NFL News:
 
Player Notes:
 
Forum Posts:
 

© 2013 RealTime Fantasy Sports, Inc.
Email Us  ·  Call Us 636.447.1170  ·  Lost Password
Advertising represented by USA Today Sports Media Group